Is it cheaper to buy things in person or online?

Whether it's cheaper to buy things in person or online depends on several factors, such as the type of product, the store’s pricing policies, shipping costs, and available promotions. Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons of both options to help you decide which might be more cost-effective for you:

1. Online Shopping:

Pros:

  • Convenience and Comparison: Shopping online allows you to quickly compare prices across different websites, helping you find the best deals without having to visit multiple physical stores. You can also read reviews to make more informed decisions.
  • Sales and Discounts: Online retailers often have exclusive online-only discounts, flash sales, or coupon codes that might not be available in-store. For example, you might find sitewide sales, first-time buyer discounts, or limited-time deals.
  • Free Shipping: Many online stores, including giants like Amazon, Walmart, and Target, offer free shipping on certain orders, especially if you reach a minimum purchase amount (e.g., $25 on Amazon) or have a membership (e.g., Amazon Prime). This can make the overall cost of shopping online cheaper.
  • No Sales Tax (in some cases): In some regions, online purchases may not be subject to sales tax (especially for stores located out of your state or country), saving you extra costs. However, in recent years, many states have started collecting sales tax for online purchases.
  • Coupon Codes and Cashback: There are often online coupon codes, or cashback sites (like Rakuten) that provide extra savings when you make purchases through their links.

Cons:

  • Shipping Costs: Shipping fees can add up, especially if you’re buying smaller items or don’t meet the minimum purchase requirement for free shipping. In some cases, shipping might outweigh the savings on a product.
  • Waiting Time: While you may find lower prices online, you'll typically have to wait a few days for your item to arrive, which could be inconvenient if you need it immediately.
  • Return Process: Returning online purchases can be cumbersome, requiring packaging and shipping the product back, which may involve fees or restocking costs.

2. In-Store Shopping:

Pros:

  • Immediate Availability: When you buy in-store, you get instant gratification. There's no waiting for shipping, and you can start using the product right away.
  • In-Person Deals: Physical stores often have in-store-only promotions or clearance sales that may not be available online. You can sometimes negotiate prices, especially for large purchases or during special sales events.
  • No Shipping Fees: There are no shipping costs associated with in-store purchases, which can make them cheaper than buying the same item online when you factor in the cost of shipping.
  • Personalized Assistance: You can often speak with sales associates who can help you find the best deal, offer discounts, or even provide advice on what works best for your needs.

Cons:

  • Limited Comparisons: In-store, you can’t always compare prices from different retailers as easily. You may miss out on better deals available at other stores or online.
  • Sales Tax: Sales tax is typically added to the price in physical stores, which can make an in-store purchase more expensive than the advertised price.
  • Limited Stock: Sometimes, the item you want may be out of stock in-store, or you may have to travel to a different location to find it.

When Is Online Shopping Cheaper?

  • Exclusive Online Sales: Online retailers like Amazon, eBay, and Wayfair often have exclusive sales that aren’t available in stores, such as Black Friday deals, Prime Day, or clearance discounts on past-season items.
  • No Need for Gas: Shopping online means you don’t need to spend money on gas or transportation to get to a store, which can add up, especially if the store is far from your location.
  • Convenience of Comparison: You can often find better prices by comparing items from multiple online retailers, and using cashback websites like Rakuten can give you extra savings.

When Is In-Store Shopping Cheaper?

  • Avoiding Shipping Costs: If you buy a small item and the online store charges high shipping fees, in-store shopping might end up being cheaper.
  • In-Store Clearance Sales: Many stores run in-store-only clearance events, which offer steep discounts that are not available online. Stores like Target, Home Depot, and Walmart often have clearance bins with high-quality items at a fraction of their regular price.
  • Instant Gratification: If you need the item immediately, in-store shopping eliminates shipping time and the potential hassle of waiting for it to arrive.

3. Hybrid Shopping (Online + In-Store):

Some stores offer a hybrid approach to shopping, where you can buy online and pick up in-store (BOPIS: Buy Online, Pick Up In Store). This option allows you to:

  • Avoid Shipping Fees: You pay online but pick up the item in the store, saving on delivery costs.
  • Skip Waiting: You can order online, and in some cases, have the item ready for pickup within hours, making it faster than waiting for shipping.

Conclusion:

  • Online shopping can often be cheaper if you’re looking for exclusive discounts, using coupons, or ordering in bulk to qualify for free shipping.
  • In-store shopping may be cheaper if you're avoiding shipping fees, if there are in-store-only promotions, or if you’re purchasing smaller items that you can carry home immediately.

Ultimately, whether in-person or online shopping is cheaper depends on your specific purchase, how well you can compare prices, and the additional costs like shipping and sales tax. To get the best deal, it’s often worth comparing both options for major purchases.

Back to blog