What countries have banned human cloning?
Share
Human cloning is a controversial issue, and many countries have enacted laws or regulations that explicitly ban or restrict the practice. The bans are often based on ethical, moral, and scientific concerns regarding the potential consequences of cloning, particularly human reproductive cloning. Here's a breakdown of countries and international agreements that have banned human cloning:
1. United States:
-
Reproductive Cloning: There is no federal law banning human cloning outright, but several states have enacted their own laws prohibiting reproductive cloning.
- For example, California and Michigan have laws that criminalize reproductive cloning.
- Therapeutic Cloning (also called somatic cell nuclear transfer) is regulated at the federal level. Some federal lawmakers have sought to ban it entirely, while others support it for stem cell research.
- In 2005, the Human Cloning Prohibition Act was introduced in the U.S. Congress, which would have banned both reproductive and therapeutic cloning, but it did not pass.
2. European Union:
- EU Directive 2001/20/EC: The European Union has a common approach toward human cloning, with an emphasis on ethical concerns related to the manipulation of human embryos.
- Reproductive cloning is strictly prohibited in all EU member states under the Council of Europe’s Oviedo Convention (1997), which deals with human rights and bioethics.
- Therapeutic cloning (for stem cell research) is allowed in some countries under strict regulation, but it is highly controversial.
3. United Kingdom:
- The Human Reproductive Cloning Act (2001) specifically bans human reproductive cloning, meaning creating a genetically identical human being.
- Therapeutic cloning is allowed for research purposes, including stem cell research, with strict regulations. The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) oversees all cloning and stem cell research in the UK.
4. Canada:
- Human Cloning Act (2004): Canada has laws that explicitly prohibit human cloning, including both reproductive and therapeutic cloning. The Assisted Human Reproduction Act bans the creation of cloned human embryos and other reproductive technologies.
- Penalties: Individuals who engage in human cloning can face severe penalties, including jail time.
5. Australia:
- Australia enacted the Human Cloning Act (2002), which bans both reproductive human cloning and the cloning of human embryos for research.
- Therapeutic cloning is allowed under strict regulations for stem cell research, provided it does not involve creating embryos beyond 14 days.
6. Japan:
- Japan has no explicit law banning human cloning, but the Act on Regulation of Human Cloning Techniques (2000) prohibits reproductive cloning. Japan also has strict regulations on embryonic stem cell research.
- In Japan, somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT), the technique for therapeutic cloning, is allowed under strict ethical guidelines.
7. South Korea:
- South Korea banned reproductive cloning in 2004 under the Bioethics and Safety Act. However, therapeutic cloning (for stem cell research) was permitted until the Bioethics and Safety Act was amended in 2015, placing greater restrictions on human embryo research.
8. China:
- China has no national law specifically prohibiting human cloning, but the State Council's regulations have placed severe restrictions on human cloning and embryo research.
- Reproductive cloning is explicitly banned, but therapeutic cloning has been researched under tight regulations.
9. India:
- In India, human cloning is banned, and the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) has issued ethical guidelines for research involving human embryos. Cloning for reproductive purposes is prohibited, while therapeutic cloning is allowed under regulation.
10. Other Countries:
- France: Bans both reproductive cloning and therapeutic cloning (for human embryos), except for medical research with strict oversight.
- Germany: Bans human cloning, including both reproductive and therapeutic cloning, under the Embryo Protection Act (1990).
- Italy: Bans reproductive cloning but allows therapeutic cloning under strict regulations.
- Brazil: Human cloning is banned in Brazil, and any form of human reproductive cloning is considered a violation of human dignity.
International Treaties and Agreements:
- United Nations Declaration on Human Cloning (2005): In 2005, the UN General Assembly passed a resolution urging all member states to ban human cloning, specifically human reproductive cloning. However, the resolution was non-binding and called for ethical guidelines and legal frameworks.
- Council of Europe: The Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine (Oviedo Convention) prohibits human cloning. Many European countries have ratified the Oviedo Convention, ensuring that human cloning is illegal in most of Europe.
Summary:
Most countries around the world have either explicitly banned human cloning or implemented strict regulations. The ban typically includes reproductive cloning, but the regulation of therapeutic cloning (for research purposes, including stem cells) varies by country. Countries such as the United States, Canada, Germany, Japan, and the United Kingdom have particularly stringent laws regarding cloning.
- Human reproductive cloning is widely prohibited due to ethical concerns, while therapeutic cloning is more accepted but still highly regulated in certain countries.
- There is a growing international consensus on banning human cloning, with many countries and regions having signed agreements or passed laws to prevent cloning practices.
For more information on the global laws and regulations regarding human cloning, here are a couple of resources to explore:
